Counterfactual
The 'what would have happened otherwise' scenario that underpins additionality and baseline calculations.
The counterfactual is the imagined-but-reasoned alternative world in which the project did not happen. It is the yardstick for additionality and for the baseline, and it can never be observed directly — only argued and supported.
A sound counterfactual draws on historical trends, comparable regions and financial or barrier analysis. It should be neither implausibly pessimistic nor conveniently optimistic.
Because the counterfactual cannot be proven, methodologies impose rules and conservativeness to reduce the risk that a weak counterfactual inflates credit.
Frequently asked questions
Is the counterfactual observable?
No; it is a reasoned model of what would have happened, supported by historical and comparative evidence.
Why must counterfactuals be conservative?
Over-crediting stems largely from over-stated baselines, so conservative counterfactuals protect integrity.